Tuesday, July 28, 2009

A Hard-Headed Argument for More Art Education

As a math tutor, I often ask my students to sketch out problems. There’s nothing unusual about this. It is a common problem solving technique. Unfortunately, when students have absolutely no drawing skills, they often become so bogged down in making what should be a simple sketch of a cube, for example, that they lose sight of the bigger picture. The effect is similar to when a student becomes so absorbed by arithmetic calculations that should be automatic that he or she forgets the original purpose of those calculations.

It’s quite simple to solve this problem. Even a one semester drawing course that covers perspective would give them enough skills to make adequate math sketches. I don’t mind covering basic techniques in perspective, but it is a sad irony when schooling is so focused on math and English that students’ only art education comes from their math tutor.

Wednesday, July 22, 2009

Biology Regents Exam

The Biology Regents Exam, officially known as the Living Environment Regents Exam, is one of four science regents available to New York State students who are pursuing a regents diploma. The test itself consists of a multiple choice portion and a free-response portion. Although there isn’t a lab component, students must have completed at least 20 hours of lab work to be eligible to sit for the exam.

Students normally take the Biology Regents after one year of high school biology. Not surprisingly, the test covers the topics one would expect to find in an introductory, survey course in biology. Cell structure, genetics, evolution, ecology, and classification all make an appearance. Experimental design and data analysis are also important parts of the exam.


Merely passing the biology regents requires a grade of 65 and isn’t very difficult. In fact, it can be done with shockingly little actual knowledge of biology because a significant portion of the test consists of reading comprehension questions and questions that test students’ ability to create and understand graphs and charts. However, because of the comprehensive nature of the exam, doing very well does indicate that a student has attained a meaningful level of proficiency.

If a student fails the Biology Regents (or appears to be in danger of failure), there is usually an underlying problem that needs to be addressed, above and beyond that student’s knowledge of biology. Study habits, English language proficiency, basic literacy, learning disabilities, and commitment to school are possible problems to be considered. Possibly, the teacher’s performance should be looked into, as well.

One often-cited reason for not passing the biology regents is that the student was not allowed to take the test because he or she lacked sufficient lab hours. Unless the student was seriously ill during the school year, this almost certainly indicates a chronic problem with cutting class. If you are a parent and your child tells you that he or she wasn’t allowed to take the Biology Regents, you should look into the situation very carefully.

If your child is struggling in his or her biology class, it is important to find and address the cause sooner, rather than later. Parents should start by talking to their child about the class. Talking with the teacher, either in person or by phone, is usually the best second step. If the problem has behavioral roots (i.e., not paying attention in class, cutting class, or not doing homework) there is a lot that parents can do to help. Asking your child about the class every day, looking at his or her notebook and homework regularly, and staying in touch with the teacher are all useful. Setting clear goals and consequences is also a good idea.

An example would be something like, “If you want to go out with your friends on Saturday, I need to see you spend at least 30 minutes every weekday evening on this class.” I prefer goals that relate to effort rather than results because a student who is used to failure may feel that good results are impossible to achieve, and therefore not try.

If the root of the problem is academic, then it is important to get appropriate help for the student. For example, if your child is having trouble in biology class because of a low reading level, you might want to look into after-school tutoring. Ideally, that tutoring should address literacy and biology together. In New York City, public schools should have at least some help available after school. Private tutoring can also be very helpful.

Sometimes, the problem is not with the child, it is with the class. Perhaps the teacher is not very competent or other students are so troubled that even the best teacher would be hard-pressed to do much more than classroom management. In either case, it is a sad situation, but a motivated student with reasonable skills could still look after his or her own interests and do well on the regents (and maybe even learn some biology).

If a class is useless, I recommend either a course of self-directed study, or study overseen by a tutor. As an aside, let me say that it is my opinion that self-directed study is sometimes needlessly dismissed. It is not always realistic, but it can work- I know this from personal experience. As an eighth grader, I recognized that my teacher was not competent and took charge of preparing myself for the Earth Science Regents. I passed with a score in the high 80s (with no adult help). For students who wish to study on their own, I recommend they start by first reading the textbook and answering the study questions included in it. Next, if they can talk about what they are learning with their parents, that would be very helpful. Finding relevant documentaries to watch and perhaps popular science books to read is also a nice supplement. In the month or two leading up to the exam, studying old regents exams is a very good idea.

Of course, this type of self-study is appropriate only for highly motivated students who are starting out with very solid academic skills. For other students, private tutoring can make all the difference. If you are seeking a tutor for this exam, you should look for someone with excellent references and a strong background in biology. After one or two lessons, your child should feel like he or she is really starting to learn a lot.

When studying for the Biology Regents Exam, it is important to remember that passing the test (while important) is not the main point. The main point should be to acquire a basic knowledge of life science, and the test provides a framework for people working towards this goal.

Monday, July 6, 2009

Percentile Rank: A Case of Unfortunate Naming?

On a fairly regular basis, I’m faced with a parent who wants help interpreting some standardized test scores. Often, the test scores are in the form of a percentile rank. Many people know what percentile rank means, but in case you’re not entirely sure, it is a measure of how well someone has done in comparison to the rest of their group. For instance, if a child achieves a percentile rank of 60 on a certain portion of the ERB or ISEE, it means that he or she has done better than 60% of his or her peers. It does not indicate that the child got 60% of the questions correct. In fact, it doesn’t say anything at all about the percent of questions that the child answered correctly.

Most of the parents I work with know quite well what percentile rank means. But, they often act on the numbers as if they are percentages on a classroom test. By this I mean that they will look at a ranking of 75 percentile, as compared to independent school students (generally, an elite group) and act as if that’s an inferior score.

I suspect many parents make a subconscious connection between percentile rank and percent and therefore don’t see a 75 for what it is because that number would normally indicate something unsatisfactory.

In a way, this phenomenon is good for me as a tutor- when parents worry, I get new clients. Nevertheless, I’m not happy about it. It results in unrealistic expectations that cause both students and parents great anxiety. After all, it’s not possible for very many people to be in the 95th percentile, nor is it a measure of failure to be below it.

I believe that appropriate changes in the way scores are reported could go a long way towards alleviating unnecessary anxiety (without lowering standards). One approach might be to eliminate percentile rank and replace it with a more fortuitously named ranking system such as stanines. Stanines are a method of breaking down scores into nine groups, with the top group having a rank of nine and the bottom group having a rank of one. Stanines give roughly the same information as percentile rank and are much harder to confuse with percentage. One disadvantage is that few people understand stanines, so although the ERBs and ISEEs already report scores as stanines (in addition to reporting them as percentiles), most people overlook them. Another disadvantage of stanines is that because the groups are relatively large and all stanines are integers, two scores in a single stanine are sometimes farther apart than two scores in adjacent stanines.

Alternatively, actual percentages could be added to score reports. This would have the effect of shifting the focus to the individual student’s performance and away from comparison with the group. Of course, when it comes to school admissions, comparison with the group is most important from a practical point of view, so a percentage would not be a sensible replacement for percentile rank, merely an addition to add context.
Neither one of the suggestions I make is fully satisfactory, although I think they move in the right direction. I’m not a statistician and therefore don’t really have the tools to come up with the best way to report scores. My goal here is to point out a problem and hopefully open a discussion.