The New York Times published an article called “Students Get New Assignment: Pick Books You Like” by Motoko Rich (8/29/09) about an approach to reading instruction that reduces or even eliminates class books and replaces them with books that the students choose for themselves. In essence, this method works by allowing students class time to read each day and a relatively free rein to chose material (although teachers very well might prohibit “junk” such as “Gossip Girl”). To increase accountability, teachers monitor the number of pages that students read and require them to write about the books. Both teachers and students give reviews and recommendations to the class as a whole.
This is a thought-provoking article, which I would recommend to classroom teachers, English tutors, and parents. Ironically, I may even assign it to some of my students.
My personal feelings about the roles that free and assigned reading should play in education are complex. Part of me agrees wholeheartedly with letting students select their own books, if not from the entire domain of published works, then at least from a substantial and varied list provided by the teacher. As a tutor, it is often my job to get children to read more, and I’ve learned just how hard it is to select books for other people. Simply put, predicting what another person will like, even if you know that person intimately, is no easy task. At the same time, the only way children will read as much as they need to become truly proficient is for them to read work that they enjoy. (Have you ever noticed how excruciatingly slowly a kid will read if he or she does not like the book in question?)
As much as I like the idea of choice in reading, I have several quibbles with this approach. For one thing, I have found that students who are very reluctant readers are often even reluctant to select books. For these students, my personal experience suggests that reading teacher-selected books is an important intermediate stage for them to go through before they are ready to pick their own books.
A more fundamental qualm I have with this approach comes from me looking back at my own education. I loved reading books with my classes, and I would hate to have missed out on that experience. I would never have read most of the teacher-selected books on my own, and while I loved some and hated others, the class discussions taught me an awful lot. It is a great thing to look at a book from a wide variety of view points. A group discussion about a book the whole class has read provides this, but reading a book alone can not.
Similarly, the teacher’s input was sometimes vital to my understanding of texts, especially ones from distant times or places. For example, I read Plato’s Symposium on my own as a teenager, and I’m mildly embarrassed to admit that although I loved it, I thought it was a light, comic novel. On the other hand, with my teacher’s guidance my classmates and I were able to come to a reasonably sophisticated understanding of Antigone.
In my ideal world, English classes would share books and all students would read independently for pleasure, following their own whimsy, during free time. In reality, I realize that many, probably most, students are not choosing to fill their free time with books. With that in mind, I’m not about to criticize an approach to reading instruction which focuses on student choice.
As with so many things, I suspect the best way is the middle path. To me, it seems fairly obvious that assigned books and free-reading choices serve different purposes. Assigned reading is a chance for students to carefully analyze literature with their class, for teachers to try to stretch students’ abilities and tastes, and for children to have the experience of sharing books with their peers. Free-choice reading allows students to explore their personal interests and exercise some control over how they spend their days. It is also important to realize that if students don’t read on their own, it is very unlikely that they will become good or habitual readers. Hopefully, by requiring students to choose their own books in the classroom, teachers will be encouraging them to pick up books outside the classroom, too.
Monday, August 31, 2009
Tuesday, August 18, 2009
Review of Available SHSAT Practice Tests
The most essential tool any student needs to study for the SHSAT is high quality practice tests. There are quite a few sample SHSATs available, but they were not all created equal. Some are easier than the actual exam and a few are riddled with errors. Others are very high quality. There are four brands of SHSAT practice book readily available in most large New York City bookstores and several brands of test available online. The gold standard for practice tests are the two tests that are written by New York City and given to every student who registers for the SHSAT. In this article, I will review each one of these resources.
Kaplan has an SHSAT book that is published under at least two separate names. One is Kaplan New York City Specialized High School Admissions Test and another is Kaplan SHSAT Advanced Prep. A spot check suggested that these two books are identical. The Kaplan book has two full length practice tests and is written at an appropriate level of difficulty. Unfortunately, it also has quite a few errors. In particular, many of the scrambled paragraphs are poorly constructed and don’t necessarily have a single correct answer. If you use this book, I would recommend skipping the scrambled paragraphs and only using it to study for the other portions of the test.
The Peterson’s/Arco book is also published under more than one cover. It is even more confusing than the Kaplan book because it sometimes seems to be published by Peterson’s and other times seems to be published by Arco. Although the covers are quite different, the interior of the books appears to be identical. The title is Master the New York City Specialized High School Admissions Test and it is a clean book, with few errors. Unfortunately, it is not as challenging as it should be. Also, it doesn’t have a single full-length test. It does have 10 half-length tests, which make good supplemental study materials, but I do not recommend using them as a primary study tool. (As an aside, the Peterson’s/Arco book also contains practice material for the Hunter College High School admissions test. These tests are of very low quality- they do not accurately reflect the content of the Hunter test.)
The Princeton Review book, called Cracking the New York City Specialized High School Admissions Test, has only one full length test. The test is fairly good, but a student who seriously wants to raise his or her score will certainly need more materials. A large portion of this book consists of test taking tips and techniques. While the techniques themselves are solid (and in line with the techniques suggested in other publications) I find the tone unnecessarily snarky.
Of all the books available in bookstores, my favorite is the Barron’s, called Barron’s New York City SHSAT: Specialized High School Admissions Test. It has four mini-tests (half the length of the actual exam) and three full length tests. It is also the only book with a ninth grade mathematics supplement, which is a valuable tool for students seeking admission to the 10th grade. I like the Barron’s book because it is substantial, challenging, and contains few errors.
In addition to the tests available in bookstores, there are materials available online. Peterson’s has made three mini-tests available on line, but they are also included in the print book. Unless you can’t get to a bookstore and are in a big hurry, buying the physical book makes much more sense.
New York Academics, a tutoring agency which I own, has SHST tests available online. As of the fall of 2009, we are offering two full length, downloadable tests, with more planned for the future. These tests have been painstakingly written and edited to make sure that they accurately reflect the actual SHSAT in content and difficulty. I may be biased, but I don’t think any commercially available test surpasses the ones that New York Academics offers.
Another company that sells practice tests online is called PrepMate. They offer a package of 10 tests, which they deliver by mail. Since I am not familiar with this particular company, I was hesitant to give them my credit card information, so I sent them an email inquiring about the possibility of arranging a face-to-face purchase. Unfortunately, they did not respond. For this reason, I can not comment directly on the quality of their materials.
I hesitate to include the publication SHSAT Exam Secrets in this review, because it does not contain any practice tests. No full length tests, no half length tests, nothing! Please, don’t bother with this publication.
Of course, the gold standard for SHSAT practice tests is the tests that the New York City Department of Education gives to students who have registered for the exam. Since these tests are made by the people who make the real test, they are the most accurate representation of what the test is actually like. Better yet, they are free. (As far as I know, these are the only free tests available.) All students who plan to take the SHSAT should take these practice tests.
Kaplan has an SHSAT book that is published under at least two separate names. One is Kaplan New York City Specialized High School Admissions Test and another is Kaplan SHSAT Advanced Prep. A spot check suggested that these two books are identical. The Kaplan book has two full length practice tests and is written at an appropriate level of difficulty. Unfortunately, it also has quite a few errors. In particular, many of the scrambled paragraphs are poorly constructed and don’t necessarily have a single correct answer. If you use this book, I would recommend skipping the scrambled paragraphs and only using it to study for the other portions of the test.
The Peterson’s/Arco book is also published under more than one cover. It is even more confusing than the Kaplan book because it sometimes seems to be published by Peterson’s and other times seems to be published by Arco. Although the covers are quite different, the interior of the books appears to be identical. The title is Master the New York City Specialized High School Admissions Test and it is a clean book, with few errors. Unfortunately, it is not as challenging as it should be. Also, it doesn’t have a single full-length test. It does have 10 half-length tests, which make good supplemental study materials, but I do not recommend using them as a primary study tool. (As an aside, the Peterson’s/Arco book also contains practice material for the Hunter College High School admissions test. These tests are of very low quality- they do not accurately reflect the content of the Hunter test.)
The Princeton Review book, called Cracking the New York City Specialized High School Admissions Test, has only one full length test. The test is fairly good, but a student who seriously wants to raise his or her score will certainly need more materials. A large portion of this book consists of test taking tips and techniques. While the techniques themselves are solid (and in line with the techniques suggested in other publications) I find the tone unnecessarily snarky.
Of all the books available in bookstores, my favorite is the Barron’s, called Barron’s New York City SHSAT: Specialized High School Admissions Test. It has four mini-tests (half the length of the actual exam) and three full length tests. It is also the only book with a ninth grade mathematics supplement, which is a valuable tool for students seeking admission to the 10th grade. I like the Barron’s book because it is substantial, challenging, and contains few errors.
In addition to the tests available in bookstores, there are materials available online. Peterson’s has made three mini-tests available on line, but they are also included in the print book. Unless you can’t get to a bookstore and are in a big hurry, buying the physical book makes much more sense.
New York Academics, a tutoring agency which I own, has SHST tests available online. As of the fall of 2009, we are offering two full length, downloadable tests, with more planned for the future. These tests have been painstakingly written and edited to make sure that they accurately reflect the actual SHSAT in content and difficulty. I may be biased, but I don’t think any commercially available test surpasses the ones that New York Academics offers.
Another company that sells practice tests online is called PrepMate. They offer a package of 10 tests, which they deliver by mail. Since I am not familiar with this particular company, I was hesitant to give them my credit card information, so I sent them an email inquiring about the possibility of arranging a face-to-face purchase. Unfortunately, they did not respond. For this reason, I can not comment directly on the quality of their materials.
I hesitate to include the publication SHSAT Exam Secrets in this review, because it does not contain any practice tests. No full length tests, no half length tests, nothing! Please, don’t bother with this publication.
Of course, the gold standard for SHSAT practice tests is the tests that the New York City Department of Education gives to students who have registered for the exam. Since these tests are made by the people who make the real test, they are the most accurate representation of what the test is actually like. Better yet, they are free. (As far as I know, these are the only free tests available.) All students who plan to take the SHSAT should take these practice tests.
Tuesday, August 11, 2009
Review of The Cryptoclub
One of the holy grails of education is making math fun, without reducing its rigor. Many people attempt this task, but few succeed. I believe that Jannet Beissinger and Vera Pless are among the rare success stories with their book The Cryptoclub, Using Mathematics to Make and Break Secret Codes. This book follows a group of fictional middle-school children who form a code-breaking club. They start out with historically ancient and rather simple codes, and work their way through progressively more modern, difficult, and mathematically rigorous codes.
The Cryptoclub is not a full math curriculum that could be used on its own - there are many math concepts that children should learn in middle school that it does not touch on. Rather, it is a fabulous supplement to more traditional curriculums. Pattern recognition, probability, prime numbers, exponents, modular arithmetic, factoring, organizing data, and inverses are among the topics that the book explores in a meaningful and interesting way. Even more important, it gives young (or maybe not so young!) students an opportunity to practice rigorous critical thinking in a meaningful context. Code cracking is a great example of open-ended problems that require tenacity, organization, and creative thinking to solve.
The skills that this book teaches are similar to the skills on certain admissions tests. In particular, I use this book with my students who are preparing to take the Hunter College High School and Anderson School entrance exams. These tests may or may not contain actual code-cracking problems, but they always require students to tackle long, non-routine math problems. Another reason I like to use this book with Hunter College High School and Anderson School prep students is that both schools are astronomically difficult to get into (they are literally more selective than Harvard). With that in mind, it is important to me that my students get something valuable from their tutoring sessions whether they are admitted to the school of their choice or not. I believe that this book helps me meet that goal.
No book is perfect, and as much as I like The Cryptoclub, it does have its flaws. The story that links the characters various adventures in decoding is not very strong and a bit cheesy. It works well with 6th graders, but if I were using it with 8th graders or high school students I can imagine them being alienated by the book’s tone. I think it could still work, if a teacher acknowledged the kitsch, but it would require skill on the teacher’s part.
Another difficulty with the book is finding a place to use it. Although the book itself is relatively slim (just under 200 pages), working through the whole thing would be enormously time consuming. Even working through just a few chapters would take more time than most math teachers could spare. I can imagine it working well as the backbone of an after-school club or an elective class. One day, I hope to use it with a group of homeschoolers in the context of a supplemental math class. It is also possible for a motivated, intelligent student to use it on his or her own, although I suspect that few kids would get far with that approach.
The Cryptoclub is a textbook with extensive problems for kids to work through. There is also an accompanying workbook, which I don’t own. The workbook is a convenience rather than a necessity, as it simply repeats the questions from the textbook in a format that is more convenient for students to work with.
The Cryptoclub is not a full math curriculum that could be used on its own - there are many math concepts that children should learn in middle school that it does not touch on. Rather, it is a fabulous supplement to more traditional curriculums. Pattern recognition, probability, prime numbers, exponents, modular arithmetic, factoring, organizing data, and inverses are among the topics that the book explores in a meaningful and interesting way. Even more important, it gives young (or maybe not so young!) students an opportunity to practice rigorous critical thinking in a meaningful context. Code cracking is a great example of open-ended problems that require tenacity, organization, and creative thinking to solve.
The skills that this book teaches are similar to the skills on certain admissions tests. In particular, I use this book with my students who are preparing to take the Hunter College High School and Anderson School entrance exams. These tests may or may not contain actual code-cracking problems, but they always require students to tackle long, non-routine math problems. Another reason I like to use this book with Hunter College High School and Anderson School prep students is that both schools are astronomically difficult to get into (they are literally more selective than Harvard). With that in mind, it is important to me that my students get something valuable from their tutoring sessions whether they are admitted to the school of their choice or not. I believe that this book helps me meet that goal.
No book is perfect, and as much as I like The Cryptoclub, it does have its flaws. The story that links the characters various adventures in decoding is not very strong and a bit cheesy. It works well with 6th graders, but if I were using it with 8th graders or high school students I can imagine them being alienated by the book’s tone. I think it could still work, if a teacher acknowledged the kitsch, but it would require skill on the teacher’s part.
Another difficulty with the book is finding a place to use it. Although the book itself is relatively slim (just under 200 pages), working through the whole thing would be enormously time consuming. Even working through just a few chapters would take more time than most math teachers could spare. I can imagine it working well as the backbone of an after-school club or an elective class. One day, I hope to use it with a group of homeschoolers in the context of a supplemental math class. It is also possible for a motivated, intelligent student to use it on his or her own, although I suspect that few kids would get far with that approach.
The Cryptoclub is a textbook with extensive problems for kids to work through. There is also an accompanying workbook, which I don’t own. The workbook is a convenience rather than a necessity, as it simply repeats the questions from the textbook in a format that is more convenient for students to work with.
Saturday, August 1, 2009
Actually Understanding Physics
My scientific background is primarily in biology, with a good dollop of chemistry and a fair bit of geology thrown in. Physics was never really part of the mix for me, so when I had the opportunity to take a couple of conceptual physics classes in graduate school as part of my teacher training, I was pretty excited.
One of those classes was particularly rewarding. It was primarily a study of naked-eye astronomy (i.e., the Sun and Moon). In this class, we did some just plain awesome things - most notably, we taught ourselves to tell time by looking at the moon. Most of my classmates were like me - science teachers (or future science teachers), but not physics teachers. Few of us had any significant knowledge of physics going into the course. One student, however, was different. He was a graduate student in the physics department, not the education department.
This fellow - I’ll call him John - gave me some insights into certain problems with traditional science education in general, and physics education in particular. I expected him to have a real edge in solving problems and understanding scenarios, but he did not. Without formulas to use and calculations to perform, he seemed lost. John did not have a better grasp of the big ideas in physics than the rest of the class. The only area where he showed superior performance was in mathematical ability. I don’t want to underestimate the importance of math, but being able to solve equations while being unable to explain the ideas in words seems a little like being a dancer who is physically fit enough to perform breathtaking stunts, but who lacks musicality and expressiveness.
Now, I am aware that there is an excellent chance that John had been assigned to that particular introductory-level class because his professors realized that he had an unusually poor understanding of conceptual physics. Nevertheless, I think he is symptomatic of a larger problem. Too often, science classes are structured in a way that emphasizes memorization over reasoning. These classes may appear to be rigorous, but instead of promoting high achievement, they often quash interest in science and most of their victims do not retain significant knowledge after the final exam is over. Because of the focus on details of problem solving, it is possible to do well in such a class without actually seeing the big picture.
In physics, there is currently a movement to correct this problem by teaching the subject first in a conceptual way, with relatively little mathematics. The goal of conceptual physics is not to eliminate math but rather to use it as a tool in the service of ideas. In this model, all students should leave high school with the ability to discuss Newtonian physics verbally and make accurate, qualitative predictions about the physical world. Students with a desire to deepen their knowledge of physics can then go on to take more math intensive, quantitative physics courses.
Given my strongly positive experience with conceptual physics, I am obviously a proponent of this approach. Indeed, I would like to see other sciences, especially chemistry, take note of this trend. If you would like to learn more about conceptual physics, I recommend Conceptual Physics for Everyone by Paul Hewitt and Physics by Inquiry by Lillian McDermott.
Oh, and John? By the end of that class, he was more proficient at solving equations, and able to discuss physics in words, too.
One of those classes was particularly rewarding. It was primarily a study of naked-eye astronomy (i.e., the Sun and Moon). In this class, we did some just plain awesome things - most notably, we taught ourselves to tell time by looking at the moon. Most of my classmates were like me - science teachers (or future science teachers), but not physics teachers. Few of us had any significant knowledge of physics going into the course. One student, however, was different. He was a graduate student in the physics department, not the education department.
This fellow - I’ll call him John - gave me some insights into certain problems with traditional science education in general, and physics education in particular. I expected him to have a real edge in solving problems and understanding scenarios, but he did not. Without formulas to use and calculations to perform, he seemed lost. John did not have a better grasp of the big ideas in physics than the rest of the class. The only area where he showed superior performance was in mathematical ability. I don’t want to underestimate the importance of math, but being able to solve equations while being unable to explain the ideas in words seems a little like being a dancer who is physically fit enough to perform breathtaking stunts, but who lacks musicality and expressiveness.
Now, I am aware that there is an excellent chance that John had been assigned to that particular introductory-level class because his professors realized that he had an unusually poor understanding of conceptual physics. Nevertheless, I think he is symptomatic of a larger problem. Too often, science classes are structured in a way that emphasizes memorization over reasoning. These classes may appear to be rigorous, but instead of promoting high achievement, they often quash interest in science and most of their victims do not retain significant knowledge after the final exam is over. Because of the focus on details of problem solving, it is possible to do well in such a class without actually seeing the big picture.
In physics, there is currently a movement to correct this problem by teaching the subject first in a conceptual way, with relatively little mathematics. The goal of conceptual physics is not to eliminate math but rather to use it as a tool in the service of ideas. In this model, all students should leave high school with the ability to discuss Newtonian physics verbally and make accurate, qualitative predictions about the physical world. Students with a desire to deepen their knowledge of physics can then go on to take more math intensive, quantitative physics courses.
Given my strongly positive experience with conceptual physics, I am obviously a proponent of this approach. Indeed, I would like to see other sciences, especially chemistry, take note of this trend. If you would like to learn more about conceptual physics, I recommend Conceptual Physics for Everyone by Paul Hewitt and Physics by Inquiry by Lillian McDermott.
Oh, and John? By the end of that class, he was more proficient at solving equations, and able to discuss physics in words, too.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)