Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Review of Singapore Math Curriculum

I’ve used Singapore Math’s elementary level math books (through grade 6) extensively, and I think that they are an excellent basic curriculum, but only if they are used in conjunction with materials that provide a dose of more open-ended and inquiry-based math.

Singapore Math is very well thought out and thorough. It covers topics in an extremely logical sequence and, with the exception of long division, introduces topics in a way that makes even tough topics accessible. The books have a very clean, almost spare feel to them. There aren’t a lot of bells and whistles but the exercises are really well done. I can imagine that Singapore Math books might not sell well if they were placed side by side in a bookstore with glossier books, which is a shame because they are really very solidly built.

On the other hand, I think that the elementary series of Singapore Math has one significant flaw and one relatively minor flaw. The significant flaw is that the series does not do enough to foster creative problem solving. True, the series present a great many excellent problem solving strategies and in the supplemental books there are problems difficult enough to challenge nearly any student. But, the problems generally have the same “favor”. I can easily imagine a student raised on Singapore Math becoming quite flustered when presented with messier, more real-world style problems. (Of course, this is true for most other curriculums, too.) When I teach homeschool students using Singapore Math, I simply make sure to periodically supplement their studies with more open-ended and inquiry-based math from other sources.

The minor problem that I have identified with Singapore Math is the way in which long division is introduced. For some reason, Singapore Math jumps directly into long division problems with remainders which is an unnecessarily confusing, even traumatic, way to go about things.

In a nutshell, I use and recommend the elementary Singapore Math series, as long as the instructor is conscientious about regularly supplementing the basic curriculum with open-ended and inquiry-based material from other sources.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Singapore math produces great test results.

That makes for stunning headlines and it can be proven to be true. So, let's all pack up our books, teach our children and watch them thrive in the world.

Umm… no. You asked for great test scores, not necessarily great learned students. Singapore math doesn't produce great mathematicians. It is a method designed to produce great math test scores; it teaches to the tests, but little else.

When (attempted) to be used in the real world, it is very slow. When someone tries to prove their results to a co-workers, possibly double-checking their results, it approaches uselessness. A uselessness that rises exponentially with the complexity of the problem.

My nephew came to me with a simple problem of how to (quoting from his text book) "double the size of the swimming pool". Surface area? Volume? It never said. So, let's play it safe and just double the length and that will net a doubling in, both, the surface area AND volume, right? No, that was the wrong answer - they wanted the student to double the length AND width. On what planet is that a "doubling" of the "size"? You'd be quadrupling it.
(Did I mention I have a B.S. in Engineering?) They WANTED, but never asked for, a doubling of the perimeter.

First off, a pool is a 3D object, much like a cup of coffee, and should be used as such in examples. Next, "size" is a highly ambiguous term. Much like, "Which number is bigger; 12 or 1.49823434883939848412323980983?" One gives you more donuts and the other has 30 digits.

These text books are allegedly designed for the student to read with very little supervision (explaining its viral spread and use by lazy and/or incompetent homeschooling parents), but I find Singapore math to require MORE parent and teacher interaction, as well as time and effort upon the student… for an incredibly small amount of advantage outside of the classroom.

Too many students spend more time trying to shoehorn (that shows my age) the problem into a method rather than getting directly into the problem. It's like waiting 30 minutes for the Singapore Bus rather than taking 15 minutes to walk to your destination. Heaven help you if you're in a place you can't use a Singapore Bus.

Singapore Math is king only where SAT scores are God.