It’s an old story- kids have been having trouble with word problems for a long time, probably since word problems were invented. Elementary school children have trouble with word problems and high school seniors do, too. This problem plagues public schools, private schools, and parochial schools. It’s found in wealthy areas and poor areas. It seems to be practically universal. Why is this?
Sometimes it’s very easy to see why a particular student is having trouble with a word problem. Let’s invent a 4th grader named Bob. Bob likes getting good grades and praise from his parents and teacher, but he doesn’t much care for homework. He’s got better stuff to do! So when it’s time for him to sit down and do his homework, he rushes through it as fast as he can. He skims the word problems, looking for the key words that his teacher taught him. Let’s look over his shoulder for a moment and see the problem he’s working on:
Sally is making lunch for 4 people. She wants each person to get two sandwiches and 3 cookies. What is the difference between the number of slices of bread and the number of cookies she must have?
Ahah! He sees the word “difference” and knows there must be subtraction in the problem. Easy. 4-3=1. Moving on to the next one..
And so Bob gets the problem wrong.
It was probably easy for you to see that Bob got his problem wrong because he didn’t read the problem carefully enough. Of course, as any parent knows, just saying “Do your work more carefully!” is unlikely to get results. As a tutor, I have a variety of techniques to force students to be more careful. One of my favorites for elementary school children is to have them draw pictures of the problems that they get wrong or have trouble understanding. In this case, after drawing a picture of the situation, Bob would almost certainly understand his mistake and how to correct it.
Or maybe the situation is a little more complex. Let’s look at a fictional 10th grader, Lisa. Lisa is a conscientious student, but she never especially liked math and as the years have gone on, she’s become less and less confident in her skills. Her class is reviewing rates and she’s working on this problem:
If Curly can paint a fence in 8 hours and Moe can paint the same fence in 4 hours, how long would it take them to paint the fence if they worked together?
Lisa thinks for a minute, and then writes down 6 hours, since this seems kind of like a situation where an average would be appropriate. She’s a little bothered by this answer, but she’s used to not feeling very sure about math so she just shrugs off the feeling and moves on to the next problem.
As a tutor, when I see this type of mistake I speak to my students about the importance of estimating- and then paying attention their estimates. Lisa’s key error here (and it is a very common one) was that she didn’t trust her own judgment. If you think about this problem for a moment, it’s probably not hard for you to see that the Curly and Moe should finish painting the fence together more quickly than either of them could working alone. So immediately, it becomes clear that the answer must be less than 4 hours.
(If you’re having trouble solving this problem here’s a hint - What fraction of the fence could Curly paint in one hour? What fraction could Moe paint in one hour? What fraction of the fence could they paint together in one hour?)
There is no single solution when a student struggles with word problems. Undoubtedly, that’s a big part of what makes this such a challenging area to teach. It’s also the reason why tutoring can be particularly effective in this area- students really do benefit from individualized attention when there is no one-size-fits-all solution.
No comments:
Post a Comment